By Oliver Radcliffe / 9 July 2026

A Guide to Blind Crisp Tasting at Home

A Guide to Blind Crisp Tasting at Home

Why Blind Tasting Beats Brand Loyalty

Most of us know exactly which bag we like, right up until the packaging is taken away. A bold colour scheme, a familiar name and thirty years of habit do an enormous amount of persuading before the first crisp even reaches your lips. Blind tasting removes all of it. It is one of the cheapest, most enjoyable experiments you can run in a kitchen, and it will genuinely change what you reach for next time.

The method is straightforward: strip out every clue, number the bowls, and ask your tasters to write before they speak. What follows is a practical guide to running it properly, plus a short detour into making your own crisps so you have a benchmark to measure everything else against.

Setting Up the Table

You need far less equipment than you think, but the small details matter more than the big ones. Use identical bowls, preferably white or plain glass so nobody is influenced by colour. Number them on the base with a marker, not the rim, so nobody can peek. Keep the packets well out of sight — a closed cupboard is fine, a bin bag in the hallway is better.

  • Tasters: four to six people is ideal. An odd number breaks ties without a debate.
  • Samples: four to six varieties. Beyond six, palates tire and everything starts tasting of salt.
  • Reset kit: plain water at room temperature and a few unsalted crackers. Nothing flavoured, nothing fizzy.
  • Score sheets: one per taster, one column per sample, four scoring rows.

Serve crisps at room temperature. Cold crisps taste flatter, and the aroma is muted, which unfairly penalises whichever sample happens to come out of a chilly cupboard. Pour roughly the same number of whole, unbroken crisps into each bowl — about eight to ten is plenty for scoring purposes.

Choosing and Preparing the Samples

Aim for variety with at least one obvious overlap. A good first flight might be two ready salted, two cheese and onion, one salt and vinegar and one hand-cooked crinkle-cut. That way you get direct comparisons within a flavour family as well as across the whole table.

If you are comparing brands, keep the cut consistent where you can. A thick, hand-cooked crisp will beat a thin one on crunch every single time, which tells you something about texture but nothing about flavour. Better to run two flights: one for thin-cut, one for thick-cut.

Decant each sample into its bowl in a separate room if you can, and wash your hands between packets. It sounds fussy. It also stops the salt and vinegar from following you around the kitchen like a bad smell.

The Score Sheet: Four Things That Matter

Score each sample out of five on four separate dimensions. Whole numbers only; halves encourage hedging. Write a short comment next to every score, because three weeks later you will not remember why you gave a four.

  • Aroma: Snap one crisp in half near your nose before eating. Look for fresh potato, clean oil, and a seasoning that reads as what it claims to be. Stale oil and a faint cardboard note are the common faults.
  • Crunch: Note the first bite and the follow-through separately. A good crisp shatters cleanly and then gives way; a poor one either bends, or explodes into dust with no substance behind it. Listen as well as feel.
  • Seasoning: Judge balance, intensity and evenness. Is the salt sharp or round? Does the flavour arrive at the front and vanish, or build? Check a second crisp from a different part of the bowl — uneven coating is a real flaw and easy to miss on the first bite.
  • Aftertaste: Wait a full thirty seconds. Note length, oiliness and whether the mouth feels coated or clean. This is where cheap frying oil gives itself away, and where the best samples quietly win.

Keeping the Tasting Honest

The single most important rule is silence. No discussion, no raised eyebrows, no "ooh, that one's nice" — until every sheet is completed and folded. One enthusiastic comment can shift an entire table's scores, and the effect is well documented.

Order matters, so shuffle the bowls between tasters and keep the sequence different for each person. Strong flavours dull the palate for whatever follows, so serve lighter samples earlier if you are running a fixed order. Between samples, sip water and nibble a cracker.

Finally, tally the scores in a separate room and reveal the results together. The gap between what people expected and what they scored is usually the most entertaining part of the evening.

Making Your Own Crisps as a Benchmark

Nothing sharpens your judgement like frying a batch yourself. Use floury potatoes, slice them two to three millimetres thick on a mandoline, then soak the slices in cold water for twenty minutes to rinse off surface starch. Dry them thoroughly — a salad spinner followed by a tea towel works well.

Fry at 160°C until they stop bubbling and turn pale, lift them out, then raise the oil to 180°C and fry again briefly for colour. Drain on a wire rack, never on kitchen paper, which steams the underside soft. Season the moment they come out of the oil, while the surface is still glistening.

Oven-baked versions work too: toss the dried slices in a thin film of oil, spread them in a single layer and bake at 180°C, turning once. They will never be quite as shatteringly crisp, but they make an excellent low-effort control sample.

Set your homemade batch alongside the shop-bought ones in the next tasting. You will learn more from one comparison than from a dozen bags, and you will have a very good excuse to eat the leftovers.

Avatar

Jhon Bentham

Hi, my name is Anthony kuber. I am artist and fashion designer.
I love to travel and writing blogging.

Write your opinion

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Top Picks
      
Avatar

Diva Gonzales

Software Developer & Writer

Hey, I'm Diva, a developer and writer blending code and creativity. I'm driven by a deep curiosity and a relentless pursuit of excellence. Join me as I craft digital solutions and captivating stories.

Banner Ad

Subscribe

Be the first to access exclusive content and expert insights by subscribing to our newsletter!